Raw Aus Pol

← Media bias

Same news, different party

The claim: when Labor governs, its wins get a line and its failures get the front page. When the Coalition governs, the reverse. The fair test isn't whether a paper is negative about Labor. Every paper is hard on whoever governs. It's whether the same paper treats Labor governments worse than it treated Coalition ones, and worse than other papers do.

What we've found

The Courier-Mail: Labor vs the LNP Same paper, same city, different party. Under Labor, 46% of its political front-page stories were unfavourable to the state government; under the LNP, 19%. It ran nine front-page campaigns against Labor, and one, aimed at federal Labor, under the LNP. Its coverage of two Olympic stadiums followed the same pattern, and so did the Brisbane Times and the ABC.

Is the Herald Sun harder on Labor? 423 Herald Sun headlines on Victorian state politics, 2011 to 2026, against The Age. Under Labor, 44% were unfavourable to the government; under the last Coalition government, 27%. The Age was about even. Its good news for Labor came as one-off headlines; its bad news came back month after month.

Premier vs Opposition: who gets the headlines? Every Herald and Telegraph headline on the NSW Premier and Opposition Leader across two elections and two mid-terms. The opposition vanishes between elections, whichever party it is.

How each outlet treats each party

How each outlet's headlines treat each party, counting only headlines that name or clearly target it. ▲ favourable, ▼ unfavourable, ○ neutral.

Also: the Courier-Mail's coverage of youth crime laws under each party is on the Courier-Mail page, and how outlets balance their coverage only in the final weeks of a campaign is on They decide what you think about.