Raw Aus Pol

← Media bias

Premier vs Opposition: who gets the headlines?

In How to solve a problem like friendlyjordies, friendlyjordies says the Sydney Morning Herald put Premier Gladys Berejiklian in its headlines about 103 times in a month, against 3 for Labor's Jodi McKay, two of them negative. The suggestion: the paper gives the government the stage and starves the opposition. A second idea goes with it: that papers report fairly enough mid-term, but turn into campaign material in the six months before an election.

So we counted. Every headline in the Herald and the Daily Telegraph naming the NSW Premier or Opposition Leader, in the six months before the 2019 and 2023 elections, and in a mid-term stretch after each. Then we had each headline rated for how it treats the leader, by a rater who wasn't told the paper, the date or the party.

Raw Aus Pol's read: Jordies is right that the Opposition Leader almost vanishes between elections. In six months mid-term, McKay got Herald headlines. But it isn't about Labor: under a Labor premier, the Liberals' Mark Speakman got . Both papers hand most of the space to whoever is Premier, and little of it is flattering.

Party shows up at one paper, once. Before the 2019 election, about half the Telegraph's headlines on Labor's leaders were unfavourable, against under a third for Premier Berejiklian, and it was harder on her mid-term than in the run-up. That's the pattern you'd expect if a paper turns into campaign material near an election. But before 2023 the Telegraph treated Perrottet and Minns about the same, and the Herald was, if anything, gentler on Minns. One election out of two, at one paper of two: worth watching, not proven.

How many headlines each leader got

Headlines naming the Premier or the Opposition Leader, or referring to them by title. A headline naming both counts for each.

How kindly

Each headline rated favourable, neutral or unfavourable to the leader it names, from its wording alone. A straight report of bad news is neutral. Leading with an attack on them, a scandal, a gaffe or a revolt counts as unfavourable.

FavourableNeutralUnfavourable

Mid-term opposition rows have only a handful of headlines, so their percentages mean little. That near-silence is the finding.

The month Jordies was talking about

October 2020, when ICAC's hearings revealed Berejiklian's secret relationship with former MP Daryl Maguire, and the phone call where she told him "I don't need to know about that bit". We found Herald headlines about her that month, from its NSW politics section and stories naming her in the web address, so the true count is higher. McKay got 1. A separate rater sorted each by what it puts first:

Half the month's headlines were about whether she'd survive: resignation, no-confidence votes, her popularity, who'd replace her. About one in four were about public money and decisions in office. A corruption hearing, covered mostly as a question of whether the Premier keeps her job. It's the same pattern we see at election time: the contest crowds out the substance.

Every headline

Show all headlines

Method and limits

Collection: every story in each paper's daily sitemaps for the four windows, with the headline taken from the story page. Herald: everything in its NSW politics and NSW news sections, plus any story whose web address names a leader, so the count is close to complete. Telegraph: it has no separate NSW politics section, so we checked stories whose web address names a leader, plus its election sections. Its counts are a floor. Collected .

About the Telegraph's terms: the Telegraph's robots.txt asks automated tools not to collect from the site without written permission. We used only public pages, no paywalled text, and published counts and headlines, not articles. We won't collect from News Corp sites automatically again without permission; future Telegraph checks will be done by hand.

Rating: one rater rated all 1,050 leader mentions without being told the paper, the date or the party. A second rater re-rated a random 105 and agreed on . Tone is judged from the headline only, not the story.

Real events matter. Unfavourable headlines often reflect genuinely bad news, such as a scandal, a gaffe or a lost vote. Michael Daley's 2019 campaign ended with a recording of him saying young Sydneysiders were being replaced by migrants from Asia, which no paper could report kindly. This test shows how each paper treated each leader, not whether that treatment was deserved.

Not tested: placement (front page or page 25), the stories under the headlines, TV and radio. Luke Foley's last day as leader (8 November 2018) is left out.

Raw Aus Pol is openly pro-Labor. The result here doesn't match what we expected going in, and we've reported it as found.