How we rate things
The rules behind everything on this site, in one place, so you can check whether we follow them.
Where we standSourcesPromise trackersScorecardsScandalsPollsMedia biasGames and satireCorrections
Where we stand
Raw Aus Pol is openly pro-Labor, and leans to the Greens on some things. It's run by a private individual, isn't paid by anyone, and isn't endorsed or authorised by any party. Our opinions are labelled as ours ("Raw Aus Pol's read", "My recommendation"). Our facts aren't opinions: they're sourced, and we report the ones that hurt Labor too.
Sources
- Every fact links to its source. A "(source)" link should say what we say it says; if it doesn't, that's a correction.
- Primary sources first: budget papers, electoral commissions, the ABS, Auditors-General, courts, parliament and official reports. Then reputable news.
- Claims are labelled as claims. A government's own figures say "(government figures)"; a council's say "(council figures)"; a party's attack on another party says whose claim it is.
- Allegations are allegations. We say who alleged it, include the denial where there is one, and say when nothing has been proven.
- We read what you can read. No paywall workarounds: no archive copies of paywalled articles, no tricks. If we can't see it, we don't cite it.
- Wikipedia is a starting point, not a source. We use it to find primary sources. Where something still rests on it, we say so.
Promise trackers
We track what a government promised at its election, using the promise as it was made at the time where we can find it.
- Kept
- Delivered substantially as promised.
- In progress
- Under way. Each comes with an outlook: on track, running late, scaled back, unlikely as promised, or too early to tell, with a one-line reason.
- Not yet
- Nothing has happened yet, and the term isn't over.
- Missed target
- Broken by falling short: late, smaller, or not quite what was promised.
- Broke the spirit
- Abandoned, or the government did the opposite.
We don't mark a promise broken just because it isn't finished if the promise was only to start or fund it, or the deadline hasn't passed. Progress bars appear only where there's a sourced number. "Not promised, but done" sections cover big things a government did without promising them; they don't count in the score. Where a tracker's promise list is weaker than we'd like (for example, a mayor with no published platform), the tracker says so at the top.
"Our take": was it a good idea? Kept or broken says whether a government did what it said. It doesn't say whether what it said was worth doing, and a government that keeps its bad promises and breaks its good ones still scores well on a plain count. So on some trackers we also give our opinion on each promise: good idea, bad idea or mixed, with a one-line reason, and a table that crosses the two (kept or broken, good or bad). This is opinion, from where we stand (see above), and it's labelled as ours. The reasons lean on the evidence where there is some, such as what a policy cost, what it did to emissions or reoffending, or what auditors found. They're kept separate from the kept/broken score, which doesn't change.
Scorecards: "Better or worse?"
Used on State of the States and State of the Council.
- One measure per area, chosen before we look at the result.
- Compare the latest figure with about three years earlier. A change of less than about 3% either way is "maintaining". Otherwise it's improving or getting worse, in whichever direction is better or worse for residents.
- If other measures disagree, we say so in the caveat, rather than changing the rule to get a nicer answer.
- Each state is compared with its own past, not with other states, because states measure some things (like crime) differently.
- Population is a trend, not a verdict. More or fewer people moving to a state isn't simply good or bad, so it's shown in grey as rising, steady or falling, and left out of the better/worse tally.
- Where government changed inside the three years, the verdict covers both governments, and we say so.
Scandals
Scandals aren't equal, so we don't just count them. Each is tagged by kind: public money and power (how a government spends money or uses power), candidate or MP conduct, or party turmoil. The first kind usually matters most, and we weigh it most, including for Labor. Each item says what it means for voters, and findings by courts or integrity bodies are quoted exactly.
Polls
We show the latest published poll with its pollster, dates and sample, plus a table of recent polls. Not every poll publishes a two-party figure; where the latest doesn't, the two-party bar shows the latest poll that did, and says which. Polls are snapshots, not forecasts.
Media bias
We rate whether a headline fits its story: fair (it sums up the story's main point), spin (it leans beyond what the story supports) or misleading. Ratings are made without seeing which outlet ran the story where possible, and a second rater re-checks a sample. We rate headlines and outlets, not individual journalists. The main question we care about is proportionality: what gets attention, and what gets ignored. See the media bias work.
Games and satire
Satire is labelled as satire. The jokes are ours; the facts inside them aren't made up. In Sell-out Victoria! every brick is a real, sourced commitment, and Happy Drive's street names are real removed level crossings. Each game lists its sources and a "to be fair" note on the other side's record.
Corrections
When we get something wrong, we fix it and log it on the corrections page: what we said, what's right, and the source.
