The Courier-Mail: Labor vs the LNP
Queensland is the cleanest test we have. Same paper, same city, same editors, but Labor governed until October 2024 and the LNP has since. If the paper's treatment of the state government changed when the party changed, that's hard to put down to anything else. We checked three ways: its front pages, its headlines, and how it covered two Olympic stadium decisions, one by each party.
The short answer: the front page changed sharply. Under Labor, 46% of the Courier-Mail's political front-page stories were unfavourable to the state government. Under the LNP, 19%. The paper ran nine front-page campaigns against the Labor government, on land tax, the GP payroll tax, youth crime and the Gabba. Under the LNP it has run one, and that one targeted federal Labor.
1. The front page
Every front-page story on the 1st and 15th of each month, November 2021 to October 2026, from the library's newspaper archive.
| Government | Political front-page stories | Unfavourable to the state govt | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Labor, Palaszczuk | 65 | 42% | |
| Labor, Miles | 25 | 56% | |
| Labor, all | 90 | 46% | |
| LNP, Crisafulli | 36 | 19% |
- Counting only lead stories: 58% unfavourable under Labor, 27% under the LNP.
- Counting only stories about the state government itself: 69% unfavourable under Labor, 41% under the LNP.
- Under the LNP, the paper's front-page fire moved to Canberra and to the state Labor opposition.
Under Labor:
- "TAX HIT TO LIFT UP RENT" (land tax campaign, Sep 2022)
- "YOU'LL PAY THE GP TAX" (Feb 2023)
- "NAILED TO THE WALL" (Cross River Rail cost blowout, Apr 2023)
- "LOCK KIDS UP MILES ACTS" (May 2024)
Under the LNP:
- "NEW LAWS FAIL TEST" (youth crime laws, Jan 2025, unfavourable)
- "CANCER BUNGLE" (Mar 2025, unfavourable)
- "SHAKE IT OFF PROTESTERS" (stadium work begins, Jun 2026, favourable)
- "Vic Park ban foiled" (Jan 2026, favourable)
2. The headlines
Online headlines on Queensland state politics, the 15th of each month, November 2021 to October 2026, with the Brisbane Times as a comparison.
| Paper | Unfavourable under Labor | Unfavourable under the LNP |
|---|---|---|
| Courier-Mail | 56% | 41% |
| Brisbane Times | 34% | 35% |
The Brisbane Times treated both governments about the same. The Courier-Mail eased off, but online the biggest drop came from Palaszczuk (62% unfavourable) to Miles (42%), so its headlines were hardest on Palaszczuk's 2022–23 integrity troubles. Its front page told a different story: there, Miles got it harder still, and the drop came when the LNP took over.
3. Two stadiums
Labor's $2.7 billion Gabba rebuild (2023) was tied to the Cross River Rail station and new housing. The LNP's $3.8 billion Victoria Park stadium (2025) came after Crisafulli said in March 2024, "If you're asking me if I support a new stadium, the answer is no", and in the 2024 campaign, "We've said we're not embarking on new stadiums". A 2025 law exempts Games works from planning, heritage and environment laws and blocks legal challenges that would delay them.
| Headlines, 6 months after each announcement | Gabba (Labor) | Victoria Park (LNP) |
|---|---|---|
| Courier-Mail, unfavourable | 35% of 23 | 16% of 31 |
| Brisbane Times, unfavourable | 43% of 14 | 21% of 19 |
| ABC, unfavourable | 62% of 8 | 15% of 13 |
| All three | 42% | 17% |
| Courier-Mail front pages | 6, 3 of them hostile | 3, all favourable |
- The Gabba was covered mostly as a cost ("Premier's Gabba fantasy: $1bn price tag simply a guess"; front page: "FANTASY FOOTBALL") and as a hit to locals and the school.
- Victoria Park was covered mostly as heritage and First Nations concerns, and as excitement ("OUR GOLDEN CITY LEGACY"; "Premier to stare down Victoria Park stadium haters"). Cost came up in 4 headlines.
- "Broken promise" didn't appear in any Victoria Park headline we found.
- This one isn't just News Corp: the Brisbane Times and the ABC were also much softer on Victoria Park.
- No independent poll asked voters about either stadium, so we can't say whether public opinion changed or just the coverage.
4. South Brisbane, 2020
In the 2020 campaign, four of the Courier-Mail's five front pages on Labor's deputy premier Jackie Trad were against her, including "LABOR'S TRADGEDY", on a seat poll the paper commissioned itself. None named the Greens candidate who beat her. On the front page, at least, it was anti-Trad rather than pro-Greens.
5. Youth crime laws
Both governments overrode Queensland's Human Rights Act to toughen youth crime laws. Labor did it in March 2023 (breach of bail) and again in August 2023, when 14 late amendments with no committee review let children be held in police watch houses. The LNP did it in December 2024 with Adult Crime, Adult Time, which Labor voted for, and again in 2025 when it added 20 more offences. UN Special Rapporteurs called the 2025 laws "incompatible with basic child rights".
| 8 weeks after each law | Labor, Aug 2023 | LNP, Dec 2024 | LNP, 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Courier-Mail: stories mentioning human rights | 85% of 26 | 27% of 37 | 29% of 17 |
| Courier-Mail: headlines unfavourable to the government | 81% | 24% | 18% |
| Guardian: headlines unfavourable | 100% of 17 | 71% of 7 | 100% of 3 |
| Brisbane Times: headlines unfavourable | 100% of 2 | 67% of 9 | 67% of 3 |
- Under Labor the Courier-Mail ran "STACIA HASN'T GOT TIME FOR HUMAN RIGHTS". Under the LNP it ran "TIME'S UP FOR YOUNG CRIMS AS LAWS PASS".
- The Guardian and the Brisbane Times stayed critical of the LNP's laws, though the Guardian ran far fewer stories on them.
- To be fair: Labor's 2023 law was a procedural ambush that drew criticism from the Police Commissioner and more than 180 organisations, while Adult Crime, Adult Time was an election promise that Labor also voted for. Some of the difference is earned. A fall from 85% to under 30% on human rights, for laws overriding the same Act for the same children, isn't.
Raw Aus Pol's read
The Courier-Mail's front page, the part people see at every checkout, went from hostile to friendly when the government changed party. Some of the Labor-era coverage was earned: the 2022 integrity scandals and the tax fights were real news. But a broken stadium promise, a law that overrides planning and heritage protections, and youth crime laws that oversight found failing got a fraction of the treatment Labor's equivalents did. Same paper, same city. The difference is the party.
How we did it
- Front pages: every page-1 story on the sampled dates, from ProQuest's newspaper archive through a State Library of Queensland membership. Rated from the headline and the database's one-line summary; photos and placement aren't visible there. One rater, who re-rated 30 at random and agreed with themselves on 27. The archive lists more editions per day before 2024, which affects counts but not the percentages.
- Headlines: 235 Courier-Mail and 191 Brisbane Times online headlines, rated with the paper and date hidden; a second rater agreed on 85% of 40.
- Stadiums: 45 headlines in the Gabba window and 63 in the Victoria Park window across three outlets; a second rater agreed on 73% of 30. The two events aren't perfectly matched: the Gabba cost blowout was news either way.
- Youth crime: 145 stories found by keyword searches of the library's newspaper archive and the Guardian's site, in the 8 weeks after each law; one rater, not blind to the government; "mentions human rights" is a keyword match; most cells are small.
- Limits: headlines and front-page wording only, not the stories under them; small samples for Miles (25 front-page stories); real events differ between the two periods. Both raters were AI (Claude), working to written rules. We publish rates and examples, not the full headline lists.
