Is the Herald Sun harder on Labor?
Every paper is tough on whoever is in government. So the fair test isn't "is the Herald Sun negative about Labor?" It's "is it more negative about Labor governments than it was about the last Coalition government, and more negative than other papers?" We rated 423 Herald Sun headlines about Victorian state politics from 2011 to 2026, and 438 from The Age as a comparison.
The short answer: yes, clearly, but not as much as people say. Under Labor, 44% of the Herald Sun's state politics headlines were unfavourable to the government, against 27% under the 2011–14 Coalition government. The Age was about as tough on both (35% Coalition, 31% Labor). Under Allan and Carroll, the Herald Sun ran about 15 unfavourable headlines for every favourable one.
Tone toward the state government
| Paper and government | Unfavourable | Neutral | Favourable | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Herald Sun, Coalition (2011–14) | 27% | 63% | 10% | |
| Herald Sun, Labor (2015–26) | 44% | 49% | 7% | |
| The Age, Coalition (2011–14) | 35% | 56% | 8% | |
| The Age, Labor (2015–26) | 31% | 60% | 9% |
Counting only headlines that are about the government, the Herald Sun was 37% unfavourable to the Coalition government and 60% to Labor governments. The Age was 45% and 43%.
Herald Sun, by Labor premier
| Period | Headlines | Unfavourable | Favourable |
|---|---|---|---|
| Andrews, 2015–19 | 125 | 39% | 12% |
| COVID, 2020–21 | 63 | 52% | 8% |
| Andrews, 2022–23 | 50 | 40% | 2% |
| Allan and Carroll, 2023–26 | 104 | 47% | 3% |
The Age over the same four periods: 34%, 36%, 26% and 25% unfavourable.
It's the framing, not the topics
The Herald Sun's mix of topics barely changed between governments. Scandal and integrity stories were about 20% of its headlines under both. What changed is how those stories were framed: 5 of its 17 Coalition-era integrity headlines were unfavourable to the government, against 37 of 68 (54%) under Labor.
The same bad stories, again and again
- Under Labor, the Herald Sun's favourable headlines were scattered one-offs: the Metro Tunnel contract, level crossings removed, drought support. Each turned up once in our sample.
- Its negative storylines kept coming back. The Suburban Rail Loop appeared in 11 separate sampled months and was never favourable. The "red shirts" affair appeared in 9 and was never favourable either. Lockdowns appeared in 8 (11 of 14 headlines unfavourable), and the CFA dispute in 6, unfavourable every time.
- Even the Metro Tunnel, now delivered, got one favourable Herald Sun headline in our sample and three unfavourable ones (trees axed, a cost claim, water leaks). The Age ran it twice favourably out of three.
- To be fair: The Age did the same to the Coalition's East West Link, 12 headlines across 10 months, 8 of them unfavourable. Repeating bad stories about governments is partly just how news works. What's specific to the Herald Sun is how one-sided it is against Labor.
Example headlines (Herald Sun)
Unfavourable
- "Dan's latest lunacy crushes Melbourne again"
- "Vic's debt soars by more than $1bn a month to $178bn"
- "Public boards stacked with Labor mates"
- "Fury as State Government axes jobs" (2011, Coalition government)
Neutral
- "Metro set for fresh rail deal"
- "Vic premier to fight for fair share of GST"
- "Government delays myki decision"
Favourable
- "Metro Tunnel contract awarded"
- "Boomgates banished as sky rail reigns"
- "Your school crossing set to get even safer"
Raw Aus Pol's read
We went in expecting something like "almost everything is negative". It isn't: about half the Herald Sun's Labor-era headlines are neutral. But the tilt is real and large. The same paper that was mostly neutral about Baillieu and Napthine has been unfavourable to Labor governments in close to half its headlines, and for the current government, favourable headlines have almost disappeared. The Age, by contrast, is about as hard on both sides. If you read the Herald Sun, you're getting a more negative picture of Labor than the evidence in other papers supports.
How we did it
- Sample, fixed before collecting: the 15th of every month from January 2011 to October 2026. We took the first three Victorian state politics stories in each paper's own daily sitemap (rolling to the 16th or 17th if short). That gave 423 Herald Sun and 438 Age headlines.
- Headlines only: we read the headline each story shows a non-subscriber, not the article. A neutral headline can sit on a hostile story, and the reverse.
- Rating: headlines were shuffled and stripped of paper and date, then rated unfavourable, neutral or favourable to the government. A plain announcement counts as neutral. Blinding is only partial: papers have recognisable styles, and premiers' names give away the era.
- Checking the rater: a second rater re-rated 40 headlines at random without seeing the first ratings, and agreed on 85% (Cohen's kappa 0.70). Every disagreement had the second rater being more negative, so our figures may be slightly low.
- Limits: the Herald Sun's online archive is thin before 2013, so its Coalition-era figure rests on 81 headlines (about ±10 points). Sitemaps aren't complete archives, and online headlines are often rewritten after print.
- Raters: both raters were AI (Claude), working to written rules. Our media bias rules apply.
- Data: we're publishing the rates and examples, not the full headline list.
