Raw Aus Pol

Simple Wins / Australian Red Tape Every step, every clock, every authority -- written down.

Legal Aid Commission (Legal Aid)

Grants legal assistance and provides duty lawyer services

State statutory bodies that assess applications for a grant of aid against means, merits and jurisdictional tests, and provide duty lawyer services at courts.

Responsibilities

A grant of legal aid requires passing three separate tests: means, merits, and whether the matter is one the commission funds at all. Each is applied separately, and failing any one ends the application.

The means test is the one that defines who the system is for, and it is set well below the point at which a person can afford a lawyer. That produces the sector's defining problem: a large population that is too well off for legal aid and too poor for private representation.

The scale of what sits underneath is visible in the community sector. Up to 70 per cent of people who reach a community legal centre have an income under $32,000 a year — and community legal centres are the service people use when legal aid has already said no.

One structural protection exists and it is worth naming, because it is the reason the system does not fail completely at the top of the criminal jurisdiction. Following Dietrich, a court may stay a serious criminal trial where an indigent accused is unrepresented. That is a backstop for the most serious matters and it does nothing for family law, tenancy, debt, employment or protection orders — which is where most unmet legal need actually sits.

Where this body appears in a process

Every point at which Legal Aid Commission can hold something up, and why.

ProcessStepWhy it waitsClockTypical
Person with a legal problem seeks assistance Apply to Legal Aid application applicant — 14
Person with a legal problem seeks assistance Means test assessment assessment — 21
Person with a legal problem seeks assistance Merits test assessment assessment — 21
Person with a legal problem seeks assistance Grant of aid, or refusal decision assessment — 14
Person with a legal problem seeks assistance Duty lawyer at court assessment scheduling — 1