The $15 billion that wasn't
For most of 2026, Victorians were told the CFMEU had cost them "something like $15 billion" on the Big Build, much of it "poured directly into the hands of criminals". Ben Carroll called a royal commission. Its first nine days of hearings are done. Here's what the evidence has turned up so far.
$15,000,000,000 claimed.
About $437,000 in improper payments alleged in evidence.
That's 0.003%.
The royal commission's budget is $50 million, about 100 times the amounts alleged in evidence so far.
Where the $15 billion came from
- It comes from Geoffrey Watson SC's report on the CFMEU, Rotting from the Top, in sections the union's administrator removed because he was "not satisfied that they were well-founded or properly tested". It became public in February 2026. (source)
- The method: unnamed "industry experts" told Watson the CFMEU added 10 to 30% to building costs. He took 15% of a roughly $100 billion Big Build. In his own words it was "a very rough estimate". It measures higher costs, not stolen money.
- Later, on 3AW, Watson said "a lot of it went into the hands of decent, hardworking people, who were getting paid at very accelerated rates" (source). In Parliament, Labor quoted him saying: "I'm not saying that this has all gone into the hands of a few corrupt individuals" (source). He still defends the number (source).
- RMIT economist David Hayward called it "little more than an informed guess" (source; his paper was commissioned by a union-linked plumbing industry body).
- It didn't stop the figure running: Jess Wilson promised to "chase down every single cent", and it was repeated in Parliament and across the media all year.
What has been alleged so far
From the commission's own transcripts of its first nine hearing days (9 to 19 November 2026).
| Allegation | Amount | Status |
|---|---|---|
| An invoice paid to a bikie-linked contractor for work not done | $165,000 | No work done, admitted; standover denied |
| "Consulting" invoices from companies linked to CFMEU figure Joe Myles | $256,000 | Denied |
| A $9,000 catering bill backed by a $20,000 quote | about $11,000 | Alleged; witness can't recall |
| A payment on the day of a CFMEU meeting | $5,000 | Unexplained |
| Fake sponsorship invoices given to the labour-hire regulator | not stated | Admitted |
| Total alleged in evidence | about $437,000 | 0.003% of $15 billion |
Evidence isn't a finding: none of these has been proven. Standover and stoppages can't be put in dollars. Sources: the royal commission; ABC reporting on day two and 19 November.
Higher costs aren't corruption
- The $400 million: a 2022–23 briefing to the transport minister forecast that moving traffic controllers onto CFMEU agreement pay rates could cost about $400 million. That's a forecast of higher wages, not money stolen, and even it is 2.7% of $15 billion.
- Gap Road, Sunbury: the level crossing at the centre of the hearings. Work stopped on 6 and 7 June 2022 over which labour-hire firm and safety reps would be used. Costs rose about $6 million, but the project's own variation report blamed a signalling delay, not the union, and the final cost came in under the original target.
- "The minister's office": the witness who said a message came from a minister's office was asked which one. His answer: "I'm assuming that."
The royal commission
Called by Premier Ben Carroll and established on 20 August 2026, with former South Australian Chief Justice Chris Kourakis as commissioner. Its budget is $50 million and its report is due on 20 August 2027, long after the election. The next hearings run from 30 November to 11 December, after polling day. (source)
Raw Aus Pol's read
Real wrongdoing in the CFMEU should be found and punished, and putting the union into administration was the right call. But the number that drove a year of headlines was a rough guess at higher building costs, sold as theft. After nine days of a $50 million royal commission, the improper payments alleged come to less than half a million dollars. The $15 billion has quietly dropped out of the coverage. The damage to Labor hasn't.
How we did it
- Amounts are those stated in the commission's published transcripts for 9 to 19 November 2026, cross-checked against ABC reporting. Each was counted once. A wider count, including union donations and cash withdrawals raised in evidence, comes to about $528,000, still 0.0035% of $15 billion.
- The commission has more hearings to come, and we'll update the total as they happen.
