Make slumlords lose their rentals
If you keep renting out a home that breaks the law, should the state be able to take it off you, pay less than it's worth as a penalty, fix it, and rent it to someone who needs it? We think yes. This page checks whether an Australian state can actually do it, how it should work, and the strongest case against it.
This is research by a non-lawyer, not legal advice. Facts are as at 14 November 2026. Where we couldn't confirm something against the law itself, we say so.
- The Constitution isn't the problem. The "just terms" rule binds the Commonwealth, not the states, and the High Court has said states can take property for less than full value. [Durham, 2001]
- Penalties aren't purchases. Taking property as a penalty for breaking a rule isn't an "acquisition" at all. In 2014 the High Court upheld the NT taking a convicted drug trafficker's home this way. [Emmerson, 2014]
- Enforcement is the problem. No state or territory licenses ordinary landlords, and we don't think a new licence is the answer. Most standards are only enforced if a tenant complains, so there's no record of repeat offending to act on.
- So build a ladder. Real standards with real offences, repairs done by the state and charged to the owner, rent redirected to the state, the state taking over management, and only then a court-ordered forfeiture. No landlord licence needed.
- The price: the home's value in its run-down state, minus what the landlord owes the state and tenants, minus a penalty set by a court and tied to the rent they took while breaking the law.
- The honest catch: it would catch few homes, the state still pays most of the value, and landlords will push back. We go through the case against it below.
What each state and territory does now
Every jurisdiction sets some standard. None can ban a landlord, appoint a manager over a private rental, or take one for breaking the rules. South Australia comes closest.
South Australia: the model to copy
- Standards
- Minimum housing standards under the Housing Improvement Act 2016
- Enforced by
- The Housing Safety Authority, which can act without a complaint and enter homes
- Teeth
- Repair and demolition orders; works done by the state and charged to the land, with a power of sale; rent paid to the state until the debt is cleared; rent caps; a public register of substandard homes
Fines are modest (up to $10,000 for ignoring an order), and we found no published numbers on how often the powers are used. [1][2]
Victoria: the toughest standards
- Standards
- 15 categories, from heating and mould to window-covering anchors; energy standards start 1 March 2027
- Enforced by
- VCAT, and Consumer Affairs Victoria's Renting Taskforce, which inspects without waiting for complaints
- Teeth
- It's an offence to let or advertise a home that fails the standards, with fines of up to about $11,000 for individuals and $57,000 for companies
By 31 August 2026 the taskforce had inspected over 600 homes and issued over 250 warnings, 130 fines worth over $900,000, and 11 court actions. Only rooming house operators face a fit-and-proper licence test. [1][2][3][4]
New South Wales
- Standards
- Seven "fit for habitation" standards since March 2020: structure, light, ventilation, utilities, plumbing, water and bathrooms
- Enforced by
- NCAT, on a tenant's application (up to $15,000 compensation); Fair Trading can issue rectification orders
- Teeth
- We found no offence for simply letting a home that fails the standards
The NSW Rental Taskforce issued almost 600 fines in its first year, but few if any were clearly about repairs or standards. Ending no-grounds evictions in 2025 didn't change the standards. [1][2][3]
Queensland
- Standards
- Prescribed minimum standards for all tenancies since 1 September 2024; a failure counts as an emergency repair
- Enforced by
- QCAT on a tenant's application; the Residential Tenancies Authority takes anonymous reports about advertised homes
- Teeth
- We couldn't confirm a penalty in the law for breaching the standards
Western Australia: no standards list
- Standards
- Only general duties to keep the home clean, in repair and lawful, plus separate rules for smoke alarms and safety switches
- Enforced by
- The Magistrates Court on a tenant's application; councils can act on their own
- Teeth
- Under a 1911 health law, a council can declare a house unfit, stop anyone living there, do the repairs and charge them to the land
In January 2026 the government's own review recommended a full standards list with a penalty, backed by 76% of people who responded. We found no bill yet. [1][2]
Tasmania
- Standards
- Written into the Act: weatherproofing, repair, bathroom, kitchen, fixed heating, curtains and ventilation
- Enforced by
- The Residential Tenancy Commissioner, on a tenant's application. We found no inspectors
- Teeth
- Each breach carries 50 penalty units, $10,650 in 2026–27
ACT
- Standards
- One: ceiling insulation, phased in by 30 November 2026, plus a general duty to keep the home fit to live in
- Enforced by
- ACAT, on a tenant's application
- Teeth
- Offences only for advertising and for ignoring an ACAT order
Northern Territory
- Standards
- No list, but homes must be habitable and meet other health and safety laws
- Enforced by
- NTCAT on a tenant's application
- Teeth
- Letting a home that isn't habitable is an offence, up to $19,400. It needs a court prosecution, and we found no sign of one ever being brought
In 2023 the High Court let Santa Teresa public housing tenants claim compensation for distress and disappointment from unfit homes. [1][2]
Enforcement is the weak point
Almost everywhere, standards are enforced only when a tenant takes the landlord to a tribunal. Tenants who complain risk a rent rise or losing the lease, and WA's own review says going to court is "costly and slow". [DRIS 2]
That matters for any "three strikes" idea: strikes can't pile up if no one records them. Victoria's public register of non-compliant rental providers listed only 18 landlords and agencies in May 2025. [ABC]
England is the warning. It has been able to ban landlords since 2018, but only after a criminal conviction, and councils prefer quicker civil fines that don't count. A 2025 University of York study found fewer than 40 published banning order decisions. [York]
Can a state take a home as a penalty?
The states: yes
The Constitution's "just terms" rule (s 51(xxxi)) applies to the Commonwealth. In Durham Holdings (2001) the High Court confirmed it doesn't bind the states. The Australian Law Reform Commission put it plainly: "the states could acquire property without having to pay just compensation". [Durham][ALRC]
Penalties are not purchases
The High Court has long held that a fine or forfeiture for breaking a rule of conduct isn't an "acquisition of property". In Emmerson (2014), the NT took all of a declared drug trafficker's property, including his home and things unconnected to crime. The majority upheld it and said how harsh a punishment should be is "a matter for the legislature". [Emmerson][Theophanous, 2006]
Two warnings from that case. The majority said a scheme aimed only at recovering costs "might raise a question of proportionality". And the dissenting judge, Gageler J (now Chief Justice), would have struck it down because it made no attempt to link what was taken to the costs involved. A good design ties the penalty to something real, like the rent taken while breaking the law.
The ACT and NT: more care needed
The territories' self-government Acts say their Assemblies can't make laws to acquire property "otherwise than on just terms". So there the penalty and the purchase must stay clearly separate: pay market value, then take the debts and penalty out of it. [ALRC][AGS on Yunupingu, 2025]
Courts must decide, not rubber-stamp
A state can't make its courts act on the government's say-so. A law that made magistrates issue control orders on the Attorney-General's declaration was struck down in Totani (2010). The NT scheme in Emmerson survived because a court decides whether the rules are met. So forfeiture should be a court's decision, after a full hearing. [Totani]
Human rights laws in Victoria and Queensland
Victoria's Charter and Queensland's Human Rights Act protect against arbitrary or unlawful loss of property. Neither can strike down an Act, but both push towards proportionality: try lesser steps first, protect innocent co-owners, and let a court reduce the penalty if it would be unjust. The ACT added a right to housing in 2025, which supports a scheme like this. [HRLC][QHRC][ACT]
How it should work: a ladder
Forfeiture should be the last rung, not the first. It's a threat that gives the lower rungs their force, and the scheme works best if it's almost never used. Each step below already exists somewhere in Australia or overseas. The numbers are our suggestions.
- Real standards, with an offenceEvery state should have a detailed list, an offence for letting or advertising a home that fails it, and inspectors who act without waiting for complaints, as Victoria does.
- A record that follows the homeOrders and breaches go on the property's title and against its owner, as South Australia already does with its repair orders. No new landlord licence: the land titles register already says who owns every home. [SA Act]
- Strikes that don't need a convictionA strike is any final finding: an unchallenged fine, a tribunal finding, or an ignored order. Only breaches after the law starts count. For example: three strikes in five years, at least one an ignored order.
- The lower rungsRepair orders; the state does the work and charges it to the title; rent paid to the state until the debt is cleared; a rent cap. South Australia already does all of this.
- The state takes over managementThe main punishment: the owner loses control of the home, not a licence. A public or community housing provider runs it, collects the rent and fixes it. New York courts appoint administrators to do this without taking ownership. [NYC]
- Agents answer with their licenceAgents are already licensed. One who knowingly keeps letting a home with an unmet repair order should face a licence inquiry, as agents already do for trust account failures. [CAV]
- Forfeiture by a courtA regulator applies to the Supreme Court, with notice and a full hearing. The court can reduce or refuse it if it would be "manifestly unjust", and must consider hardship and innocent co-owners. That safeguard is borrowed from Victoria's 2024 unexplained wealth law. [Vic Hansard]
- Tenants stay putSitting tenants keep their lease with the new public or community landlord.
- No dodgingTransfers to relatives or related companies after a second strike are ignored, company directors share liability, and the penalty survives a sale as a debt.
The price
Our bugbear first said "market value minus the repairs". The research showed that's wrong, because it counts the repairs twice. Market value is assessed on the home as it stands, and a buyer already pays less for a home with mould and broken heating. [NSW review]
So the state pays the home's value as it stands, ignoring any extra value from illegal use, such as an illegal rooming house. NSW's acquisition law already ignores value that comes from unlawful use. The state then takes out what the landlord owes: the cost of works it did, unpaid fines, money owed to tenants, and a penalty set by the court, tied to the rent collected while the home broke the law. Queensland's acquisition law already deducts unpaid rates and taxes from compensation. [Qld Act]
A unit with mould and broken heating is worth $600,000 as it stands. It has a $420,000 mortgage. The state spent $35,000 on repairs the landlord refused to do. The landlord owes $12,000 in fines and money to tenants. The court sets a penalty of $60,000, about two years of the rent collected while it broke the law.
| The state pays | $600,000 |
| The bank's mortgage is paid out | −$420,000 |
| Repairs, fines and money owed to tenants | −$47,000 |
| Court-set penalty | −$60,000 |
| The landlord gets | $73,000 |
A plain sale would have left them $180,000. But if the mortgage were $560,000, they'd have only $40,000 of equity to lose, and the rest of what they owe would become a debt that may never be paid.
Black hat: how landlords could hit back
The "black hat" is the thinking hat for caution: what could go wrong. We looked for the strongest real objections, from the people who make them, and checked them against the evidence. Each gets a verdict: Answered if the evidence is against it, Partly fair if it's real but can be designed around, and Real risk if we can't fully answer it.
What happened in 1985-87 is less dramatic than the story told about it. From July 1985 the Hawke Government stopped investors writing off rental losses on newly bought properties against their wages. Existing investments were not affected, and the rule was reversed in 1987. Grattan Institute's 2016 Hot Property report found inflation-adjusted rents were stable in Melbourne and fell in Adelaide and Brisbane. They rose rapidly in Perth and somewhat in Sydney. Grattan blames population growth and too little building while borrowing rates were high, not the tax change [1]. Saul Eslake makes the same point. Sydney's vacancy rate was barely above 1% by early 1986, and in cities with more vacancies, rent inflation fell [2].
The episode has limits as evidence. A two-year change that spared existing investments, at a time of high interest rates, is a weak test either way. It doesn't prove tax changes never affect rents, and Grattan notes that Abelson and Joyeux estimated larger effects.
In 2019 the REIA campaigned against Labor's plan, and agents sent tenants material warning that 'rents will rise'. Grattan's Danielle Wood replied that the policy would not raise rents, because when an investor sells, the buyer usually stops renting [3].
After the 2026 reform passed, Treasury estimated it would add about $2 a week to the median rent. By October 2026, Cotality data showed Sydney rents had fallen 0.4% in the September quarter and national vacancy had risen to 2.1%. Eslake said investors were pulling back, but nobody had measured an 'investor exodus' that pushed rents up [4].
The fair summary: landlord lobbies always predict renters will pay, and those predictions have mostly not come true at the scale claimed. But the e61 Institute expects rents to adjust enough to partly make up investors' losses [5], so the honest line is 'small and slow', not 'never'. New Zealand removed interest deductions for landlords in 2021 and restored them in 2024. Economists said they had no clean way to test the effect on rents [6].
Ways landlords could pass the pain to renters
Raising rents to recover costs Partly fair
The standard warning is that if you tax or regulate landlords, they'll put the rent up. In 2026 Shadow Treasurer Tim Wilson revived the Keating story, saying rents would rise as they did when Keating briefly scrapped negative gearing. [1]
Our answer: Landlords can only charge what the market will bear. In 1985-87, inflation-adjusted rents were flat in Melbourne and fell in Adelaide and Brisbane. They rose only in tight Sydney and Perth (Grattan). Since the 2026 budget, rent growth has slowed, not jumped. Some costs probably get through when vacancies are low (e61). Counter: limit rises to once a year with long notice and let renters challenge rises above market rates, as Victoria does. [1][2]
Selling up Partly fair
Victoria shows it happens. Active rental bonds fell by 21,712 in the year to June 2024. PropTrack linked about 4,900 extra investor sales to the 2023 land tax changes, though it says the cause is hard to pin down and interest rates also played a part. [1][2]
Our answer: Most sales move a home to an owner-occupier, which cuts the number of renters as well as rentals. About 35,000 first-home buyer loans were written in Victoria in the same year. Melbourne rents then grew more slowly than in other capitals. In NSW, the government reports more bonds lodged than refunded and investor lending up 23% since its eviction ban. Counter: let the state or community housing providers buy homes with the tenants still in them. [1][2]
Screening out renters likely to complain Partly fair
Landlord groups told the Scottish Government that landlords were screening new tenants more carefully under rent caps. In Australia, CHOICE found about half of renters fear being blacklisted. The Tenants Union of Victoria says some agents threaten to list tenants for things that shouldn't be recorded, such as asking for repairs. [1][2]
Our answer: Victoria has already acted. Applications must use a standard form, and landlords and agents can't ask about past disputes with a landlord or about bond history. A tenant can only be put on a tenancy database for serious breaches or unpaid debts, after the lease ends. Counter: copy Victoria's form nationally and fine agents who threaten unlawful listings. Hidden discrimination is still hard to prove. [1][2]
Retaliatory evictions and rent rises Real risk
Fear of retaliation is the main reason renters don't report problems. Greens MP Gabrielle de Vietri says 70% of Victorian renters are scared to ask for basic repairs. Protections can also be weakened fast. A month after its no-grounds eviction ban began, NSW dropped the rule that landlords show evidence for renovation evictions. The Tenants' Union said this 'further opens the door to abuse'. [1][2]
Our answer: In Victoria a landlord can no longer give notice just because a fixed term is ending. A renter can challenge a notice given because they asked for repairs, and the landlord must prove the notice is valid. But the renter still has to raise retaliation at VCAT, which is slow and intimidating. Counter: presume a notice or rent rise is retaliation if it comes within, say, six months of a repair request, and let the regulator act without a tenant complaint. [1]
Switching to short-stay letting Partly fair
If long-term renting gets harder, owners can switch to short-stay letting like Airbnb. Victoria's 7.5% short-stay levy started in January 2025. A short-stay software company said it 'hasn't moved the dial'. Professor Peter O'Connor (UniSA) says overseas crackdowns cut short-stay listings but the homes didn't move into long-term renting. [1]
Our answer: The evidence is thin either way. Australian short-stay data is patchy, and the critics are mostly from the industry. A levy alone won't stop owners switching. Counter: make short-stay hosts register, apply the same safety standards to short-stay homes, and bar a home with an unmet repair order from short-stay letting. [1]
Leaving homes empty or 'occupied' on paper Partly fair
An owner facing repair orders could leave the home empty, or use the occupancy rules to avoid the vacancy tax. Victoria's tax relies on owners reporting themselves. The Parliamentary Budget Office estimated about 900 owners were paying, against about 5,000 homes that might be liable. A holiday home is exempt if relatives use it for four weeks. [1][2]
Our answer: Victoria extended the tax to the whole state and raised the rate to 3% by the third year, and 4,631 properties paid in 2024-25. Counter: audit claims, as Vancouver does, and make a home with an unmet repair order liable whatever occupancy the owner claims. Empty homes are a small share of all homes, so this is a backstop, not a big source of new rentals. [1][2]
Hiding behind companies, trusts or relatives Partly fair
If strikes attach to a person, a landlord could move homes into a company, a trust or a relative's name and start with a clean record. We found no Australian evidence on how often this happens, but it's the obvious way around the rules. [1]
Our answer: Make orders and strikes follow the property's title as well as the people behind it, as South Australia already does with its repair orders. After a second strike, ignore transfers to associates, and make company directors share liability. [1]
Scare campaigns and rollbacks Real risk
In 2019 the REIA ran an election campaign against Labor's negative gearing policy, saying it would hurt renters. Agents including Raine & Horne sent tenants REIA material warning that 'rents will rise'. In 2026 industry groups paid for modelling that predicted bigger rent rises than Treasury's. [1][2]
Our answer: This risk is real, and these campaigns work. Labor lost in 2019, and NSW weakened its eviction rules within a month. At the time, Grattan's Danielle Wood said Labor's policy would not raise rents and that agents were abusing their position of trust. Counter: publish the evidence before the fight starts (Victoria's bond and rent data, AHURI's study), set a date in law for a review, and bar agents from using tenant contact lists for political campaigns. [1][2]
Black hat: where this plan is weak
The same test, applied to our own proposal. More objections to the wider rental fixes are on the bugbear.
Forfeiture could be struck down Partly fair
The High Court struck down South Australia's bikie control-order law in Totani (2010) because it made a court a rubber stamp for the government. A forfeiture law built the same way could fail. In the territories, a forfeiture that looks like a discounted purchase may need 'just terms'. Victoria's and Queensland's human rights charters bar arbitrary loss of property. [1][2]
Our answer: The states don't face a just-terms limit (Durham, 2001). In Emmerson (2014) the High Court upheld the NT's forfeiture of a man's home as punishment, saying whether the punishment fits the crime 'is a matter for the legislature'. A scheme should survive if a court, not a minister, decides each case against general rules, with notice, a hearing and room for discretion. The penalty should be kept separate from the purchase price. This exact design has never been tested, so say 'legally strong', not 'certain'. [1][2]
It will catch very few homes Partly fair
Tough powers go unused without inspectors and lawyers. In 2023 openDemocracy found only 16 landlords in all of England were under banning orders, partly because councils can't afford court cases, and York's researchers found fewer than 40 banning order decisions published since 2018. In New Zealand, 35 inspectors cover about 600,000 rentals. In one year they issued 316 warnings but took only four landlords to the Tenancy Tribunal. [1][2]
Our answer: That's the design. Forfeiture is a threat to make bad landlords fix things, not something we want used often. Success looks like repairs done, not homes taken. The real risk is that a threat nobody believes deters nobody: Australia's unexplained-wealth laws, with more money behind them, recovered only single-digit millions per state over several years. So fund inspectors who find problems themselves, record orders and strikes against the property's title and its owner, count unchallenged fines and tribunal findings as strikes instead of requiring a criminal conviction (York's main fix for England), and publish the enforcement figures every year. [1][2]
The state can't afford to buy homes Partly fair
Even at a penalty price the state pays most of a home's market value, then has to fix it and run it. English councils have been able to take over management of problem rentals since 2004. A 2025 University of York study found none of the councils it studied had used the power, and most lack the training or resources to manage property. [1]
Our answer: That's why forfeiture has to be the last step, not the main tool. Cheaper steps do most of the work: repair orders, the state doing the work and charging it to the title, and rent paid to the state until the debt is cleared. South Australia already has all three. When a home is taken, the state takes its debts and the penalty out of the price, and a funded community housing provider should run it. Forfeiture is a deterrent. We shouldn't sell it as a way to build public housing. [1]
The penalty hits equity, not conduct Partly fair
A landlord with a big mortgage has little equity to lose. For the same breach, forfeiture would cost a debt-free retiree far more than a heavily borrowed investor, and the bank would lose nothing. In Emmerson, Gageler J (dissenting) faulted a forfeiture scheme that made no attempt to link the value taken to the costs it was meant to recover. [1]
Our answer: That's fair. The fix is a personal civil penalty, set by the court and tied to the rent collected while the home broke the law and the harm to tenants. If there isn't enough equity, the rest stays as a debt. The real sting comes earlier: a management order takes the home out of the owner's hands, which hits borrowed and debt-free landlords the same. [1]
Innocent co-owners and honest mistakes Partly fair
Forfeiture can hurt people who did nothing wrong, such as a spouse or co-owner. A strike system could also treat a paperwork slip that was fixed quickly the same as a dangerous electrical fault. Yardney says the Greens couldn't say how a strike would be defined, or whether one incident could count as several. The Law Council has opposed removing judges' discretion from confiscation laws. [1][2]
Our answer: These are design questions with known answers. Count only final findings made after the law starts, require at least one ignored order, and treat one incident as one strike. Let the court refuse or reduce a forfeiture that would be 'manifestly unjust' and protect innocent co-owners, as Victoria's 2024 unexplained-wealth safeguards do. Keep full rights of appeal. [1]
Tenants lose out when landlords are punished Partly fair
Yardney says the policy needs a practical answer for tenants whose landlord loses a licence. Landlord groups told the Scottish Government that tougher rules mean stricter screening of new tenants, which could raise homelessness among higher-risk households. Shutting illegal flats can remove the cheapest housing. [1][2]
Our answer: The model law keeps sitting tenants in place: a management order or forfeiture changes the landlord, not the tenant. South Australia can already redirect the rent to the state and do the repairs without evicting anyone. For homes that are truly unsafe, such as a converted carport, help to rehouse tenants has to be funded before the crackdown starts. [1]
Without a licence, who catches the self-managers? Partly fair
Victoria's Greens propose a "three strikes" landlord licence, and Scotland and Wales make every landlord register, partly so inspectors can find them. Without a register, there's no list of who lets what, and landlords who manage their own rentals sit outside any duty on agents. [1][2]
Our answer: Partly fair. We don't want a landlord licence: it's a new layer of paperwork for every landlord to catch a few bad ones, and the property industry already says the Greens' version would make life harder for renters. The land titles register already records who owns every home. South Australia puts its repair orders on the title, where they bind later owners, so the record follows the property without any licence. Agents are already licensed and can lose that licence. The gap is self-managing landlords, which only inspectors who act without waiting for complaints can close. [1][2]
What we couldn't confirm
We couldn't confirm the exact wording of NSW's standards, whether Queensland has a penalty for breaching its standards, or how WA, Tasmania, the ACT and the NT set compensation when they acquire land. We found no Australian case of a state compulsorily acquiring a single problem home, and no major party, union or think tank proposing exactly this. The nearest are the Victorian Greens' "three strikes" landlord licence and the Victorian Socialists' plan to take, without compensation, homes left empty for over two years. [Greens plan][Socialists]
Updated 14 November 2026. Spotted a mistake? See Corrections.
